| Platinum | Above Ground Pizza |
| Gold | Calahan's Pub |
| Silver | New York Pizza Pub |
| Bronze | Mod Pizza |
| Top Pick | Guadalupe Brewing Company & Pizza Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Inferno's Wood Fired Oven & Spirits |
| Top Pick | Mattenga's Pizzeria New Braunfels |
| Top Pick | Mia Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Nb's Wicked Bah Pizza |
| Downtown Social |