| Platinum | Las Fontanas |
| Gold | New Braunfels Tortilleria |
| Silver | Lupe Tortilla |
| Bronze | Casa Garcia's - New Braunfels |
| Top Pick | Adobe Cafe |
| Top Pick | Adobe Verde |
| Top Pick | Chuy's |
| Top Pick | Dos Rios Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Herbert's |
| Top Pick | Mi Torito Mexican Restaurant |
| Cantina Del Rio |