| Platinum | Gristmill River Restaurant & Bar |
| Gold | Mozies Bar & Grill |
| Silver | Root Cellar Cafe New Braunfels |
| Bronze | Willie B's |
| Top Pick | Avery's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Clear Springs Cafe |
| Top Pick | Phoenix Saloon |
| Top Pick | The Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Which Wich |
| Top Pick | Wings and Rings |
| Black's Barbecue New Braunfels | |
| Cravings |